In the villages close to sweatshops, girls were substantially less likely to get pregnant or be married off (28% and 29% respectively, and this effect was strongest among 12-18 year olds) and girls school enrolment rates were 38.6% higher. Sweatshops have negative consequences for the developing countries and should be eliminated at the international level. One option might be guest worker programmes, targeted at people from the poorest countries in the world, to allow them to come and work in the developed world so that they can send more money back home for investment. However, if basic labor standards and wages were adopted at the international level, there would be no such threat to the developing countries which dare protect the rights of their citizens. This is not to condemn all work done ‘against’ sweatshops. Children of those parents who work in sweatshops grow mostly on their own; they are not able to get an education and eventually the children of these parents will form another generation of sweatshop workers. 733 Words 3 Pages. While sweatshops are not the place most Americans would choose to work, they are often the best alternative available to workers in some countries. And this is the basic argument in defence of sweatshops. In conclusion sweatshops have to many problem and cheap pay for the workers that are doing a good job in getting all of the clothes, shoes and all of the other accessories that they make. Sweatshops are "a shop or factory in. They are not a good option, but they are the least bad option currently available to many people. There are numerous sweat shops that are actively operational in the modern world. In 2001, Leila Salazar, corporate accountability director for Global Exchange, told The Guardian: "During the last three years, Nike has continued to treat the sweatshop issue as a public relations inconvenience rather than as a serious human rights matter.”. Many look at sweatshops and see only the lack of labor rights, safe working conditions, and decent wages. A sweatshop has things such as, hazardous machinery and materials, unsanitary washrooms, improper or little furniture, and fire hazards. Manufacturing facilities in developing countries are not always sweatshops. Sweatshops are Good for Everybody Essay. But what is their next-best alternative? Sweatshops with poor working conditions, forced overtime, child workers, low pay, etc are bad any way you look at it (except for the profiteers). Persuading consumers to continue buying things from sweatshops, but to pay a higher price to give those workers a better wage, might be a decent way of essentially 'bundling' a charitable donation into a normal purchase. ... To us, a nation that once sent our young to mine anthracite coal, seeing a 15-year-old assembling Nike shoes may look bad. However, the definition of “exploit” is very broad. Students during the event associated sweatshops with: long working hours, uncleanliness, low pay, poor working conditions, and more, which seems to be a standard perception of what sweatshops are to most Americans. The authors say that these effects were likely due to a combination of wealth effects (richer families need to marry off their daughters less early, and can afford to send their daughters to school for longer) and the fact that garment factory jobs reward skills, increasing the value of education. The purpose of this paper is to discuss whether sweatshops Sweatshops Controversy Essay good or bad. Furthermore, Kristof (2009) indicates that the standards of living in the regions with sweatshops soared. While on the surface, sweatshops may seem monstrous and inhumane, they actually are the lesser of two evils. in Vietnam, 59% of workers are self-employed in farming; 1.5% work for businesses owned partially or fully by foreign firms, International Labour Organisation estimates, study by researchers at the Universities of Washington and Yale, John C. Duffy and Christopher Unfortunately, most campaigns in Britain seem to be straightforwardly anti-sweatshop. In the villages close to sweatshops, girls were substantially less likely to get pregnant or be married off (28% and 29% respectively, and this effect was strongest among 12-18 year olds) and girls’ school enrolment rates were 38.6% higher. Many studies have shown that multinational firms pay more than domestic firms in Third World countries. Large corporations often use unethical and even cruel practices in developing countries to force their workers to work in such poor conditions. Surname 1 Name Tutor Course Date Sweatshops are Bad or Good Sweatshops refers to workplaces that are awful but arguments are made in defense of them. The supporters of sweatshops have several arguments warranting the existence of sweatshops. Life in a sweatshops is unpleasant and unsafe. Multinational corporations, and subcontractors alike, are only focused on quality production while neglecting the plight of its hardworking employees and yet will claim to exercise good corporate and … Sweatshop workers often work long hours for unusually low pay, regardless of laws mandating overtime pay or a minimum wage. A. The profits of large companies might slightly reduce due to eliminating sweatshops, but at the same time providing at least for basic human needs might increase the performance of sweatshop workers, drive motivation and stimulate the growth of developing economies. The fabrication processes destroy ecosystems, pollutes water, and endanger the health of garments workers. The International Labour Organisation estimates that agricultural workers suffer 250 million accidents every year, and say that in some countries the fatal accident rate is twice as common in agriculture as in other industries. Despite the bad press that sweatshops get because they do not meet American work standards, there are those that actually support sweatshops compared to the alternatives. A "sweatshop" is defined by the US Department of Labor as a factory that violates 2 or more labor laws. Obviously, there are a lot of complexities that I wasn’t able to go into in a 5 minute video. You may have heard that sweatshops abuse human rights, and that we should do everything we can to shut them down.For those of us living in prosperous countries, it is easy to lament the existence of sweatshops in the developing world. Sweatshops often have poor working conditions, unfair wages, unreasonable hours, child labor, and a lack of benefits for workers. In my opinion sweatshops are bad as they are just was to get cheap labor. Writing for the New York Times, economist Nicholas Kristof actually supports sweatshop labor over the other options these people have in his article “Where Sweatshops are a Dream”. The company disagreed. Sportswear also undergoes many chemical treatments to make it more durable, flexible, colorful, or water-repellant. I address some of those complexities in this blog post on the left-libertarian critique of sweatshops. Furthermore, it can be stopped: according to surveys of public opinion, consumers might be willing to pay 15% more for products that do not come from sweatshops, and doubling the pay of workers in such factories would only cause an increase of cost by 1.8% on average (Do Something, n.d.). And the numbers bear this out. When people argue against them, the question we should ask is: “Compared to what?”. The costs of procurement and damages are passed onto the employee instead of consumer. For example, a person off the streets gets paid 5 cents per 1 pair of jeans that they sew. This was indeed grotesque, and evidence of the poor conditions that many sweatshop workers have to work in. In 2017, Nike took a big step backwards, as International Labor Rights Forum reported that the company had turned its back on its commitment to the Worker Rights Consortium (WRC), which effectively blocks labor rights experts from independently monitoring Nike’s supplier factories. However, these arguments only show that the presence of factories in developing countries is beneficial for economic development. Three Reasons Sweatshops Are Good for the Poor.
Teacher Selection Test, Czech Republic Coronavirus Restrictions, Amy Peterson Art Bunny, House Of Gucci Movie, Royal Victoria Hospital Gynecology, Duke Boston College Highlights,