The episode included CinemaSins-themed debate topics like "Worst cinema sin" and "Most sinful movie." Where Honest Trailers gets in and out in 4 to 7 minutes maximum, CinemaSins routinely spends 15 to 20 minutes pointing out every little “flaw” in the movie under their microscope." The most popular content is the Everything Wrong With series whereby they give humorous critique on different things wrong with different movies. Rather, both companies release videos to coincide with a film's release on digital/Blu-ray or a related film's theatrical release. YouTube algorithm started to reward watch time. Vogt-Roberts' chief complaints were that CinemaSins' comments are consistently mean-spirited, they lack a clear point of view, and the series should not be considered satire. ", The Metropolist suggests that neither Honest Trailers and CinemaSins's Everything Wrong With evaluate films on their technical merits, but rather according to the feelings they evoke in viewers, and whether they feel "authentic," for example whether Prometheus feels "enough" like Aliens. Everything we see in our analytics suggests the overwhelming majority of fans prefer longer videos. Justin Bieber: Never Say Never - 13.3 billion sins. Showgirls - 69 million sins. We exist mostly just to remind you of that. That's not funny but it's also not a cliche, sin, plot hole, or continuity error, it's just a statement of fact. I can't remember the last time I saw a sinless comment. And I wasn't aware that you have specific sin percentages, so kudos on that. This means that when the co-creators left the company (at different times, under very different circumstances), the company continued making Honest Trailers without them. In Vogt-Roberts' opinion, for a series to qualify as satire, it needs to possess a clear point of view and humorous tone. In the Inside Out video, there was an incident of them sinning something in the same scene they explain it. Due to the success, CinemaSins have released seven other series. I try firing them up every once in a while but it doesn't work. Almost every video has at least one of these. I even tweeted the night before the Watchmen video about it, hinting at a few such sins. In the same article, The Metropolist wrote that the rising popularity of series like Honest Trailers and Everything Wrong With reveals that "audiences feel more and more that critics make arguments from a position of in-authenticity.The threshold for what makes a good film isn’t just higher or lower, it’s judged on entirely different criteria. Listen on Apple Podcasts. SinCast - Episode 264 - The Cheese Stands Alone. Next week: Sci-Fi '90s sins and recent horror sins. I don’t know. We’re not going to go back to 4 minute videos, because even more fans would hate that. Showgirls - 69 million sins. And with 5.5 million subscribers, it's basically impossible at this point to make everyone happy. SinCast - Episode 263 - Richard Kelly on Donnie Darko and Southland Tales. If you do not, I can only apologize. ), and even though the videos have grown longer, the percentages have stayed the same. At the very least, they’re clever in their humorous observations about critiques, plot holes and we love the new title they give to all their targets. As an example, see the Honest Trailer for Die Hard. TV Sins pretty much has the same style of CinemaSins, but instead of movies it's episodes, and sometimes TV movies. Also, a lot of the shit they point out in their videos is actually explained. From the co-creators of CinemaSins: Chris Atkinson and Jeremy Scott, who provide your favorite movie and culture nitpicking, are joined by Barrett Share from Music Video Sins, and other guests to discuss, analyze, and ridicule the world of entertainment. Before YouTube Jeremy and Chris used to work as managers at a movie theater. We NEVER set out to truly find and list all a movie's mistakes. However, the series are produced by difference companies and there are also very clear stylistic differences between them. When movies are legitimately good, Honest Trailers openly praises them, often lavishly. A brief kerfuffle erupted between the two channels in October 2015, when Screen Junkies launched a new show called "The Review Crew" which featured hosts reviewing movies while driving in cars. Movies with the most Sins. The site wrote, "While we’re supremely against all the nonsense that CinemaSins puts forth in their recurring video series, we appreciate what the folks at Screen Junkies put forth every week with their Honest Trailers. The Cinema Sins channel was created on 11 Dec 2012 and swiftly started uploading videos targeting the latest releases - first up was The Amazing Spider-Man, followed by The Avengers, The Dark Knight Rises, Prometheus, Hunger Games etc. Next week: Space sins and stop-motion sins! This website offers the most common photography products, in an extensive photo & publication section. Don't put any stock in the sin counter...they've said this multiple times. The channel has devolved into a series of lame, overused, unfunny jokes instead of offering insight first, and humour to strengthen that insight and nitpicking. The Last Airbender - 271 million sins. We're playing a character. Most sinned movie: Les Miserables, 14,508,000,000 sins (one can count Fate of the Furious since the original sin counter broke on that one) Most sinned EWW episode: CinemaSins, infinite sins; Most sinned EWW episode: Transformers: The Last Knight (until the sin counter tries to … Honest Trailer for The Amazing Spider-Man 2, The Witty Genius of YouTube’s CinemaSins: Everything Wrong with Your Favorite Movie. In 2018, the Honest Trailers post-production team consisted of editors Kevin Williamsen and TJ Nordaker, and assistant editor Emin Bassavand. It's not that you are just jokes, the new lenght of the videos open space for more funny things to say, but you comment some plot holes too, funny dialogues, errors, for example. Ding" Nitpicking is great, sinning things even as they're explained in the same scene is fine because a lot of the time those explanations are bullshit, but sinning simple statements of fact feels like padding and it hurts the delivery of sins and jokes that come after it. Honest Trailers and CinemaSins often release videos roasting the same movie on the same day. How is this not a sin? The channel produces the Everything Wrong With... series that offers critique and commentary on movies. The official subreddit of that youtube channel, CinemaSins. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. [1] In contrast, most episodes of Honest Trailers have four credited writers, with some episodes having up to six writers. I’d also point out we get a TON of direct feedback that the general public doesn’t see—email, twitter, messages through YouTube & Reddit, messages on our hotline, etc. Screen Rant noted that CinemaSins videos were originally much shorter - and were lighter, funner and, in their opinion, better because of it. Screen Rant observed that both series rose to prominence at a similar time (2012) and that they depended on one another for popularity: "despite being disconnected, in the early days they each elevated the other, creating this new brand of criticism infused with humor and a balance of traditional film theory observations and more nitpicky, nerd-focused ideas; the sort of things that movie fans would notice and mock incessantly yet never allowed to take away from the film." Screen Junkies' corporate nature affects Honest Trailers in many other ways. A know-it-all movie-obsessed nitpicking asshole. In 2014, Jeremy Scott of CinemaSins wrote "we're buddies with Screen Junkies and love their stuff, and have even collaborated several times. Everything Wrong With and Honest Trailers differ greatly in terms of production scale. OK, I used to be a huge cinema sins fan. CinemaSins. But we do actual math here… we have a specific formula for how many of the various types of sins go in each video (joke sins, intentionally ignorant sins, valid film complaints, continuity sins, recurring gags, etc. Even in their most vicious critical takedowns of cherished classics, they afford the participants forgiveness for all manner of technical missteps. In September 4, 2018 CinemaSins created a new channel called TV Sins. I read this with your voice and It was cool. Phone Word: The (possibly now defunct) CinemaSins hotline is 405-459-7466, or 405-459-SINN. He started the channel with his good friend Chris Atkinson in 2012 and who he first met while both worked as managers for a movie theater in 1999.